(no subject)
Aug. 31st, 2008 09:55 amI'm giving myself an hour to catch up on scholarly reviews. Maybe less than an hour. I was just going to catch up, but I'm not sure my mind is robust enough.
The problem is that I have just read an academic book review that makes my head whirl. There's nothing wrong with what it's saying, but there's everything wrong with how it's saying it. There are just so many specific words that are used where really the writer wants to say something general. As a result, all the very precise implications of 'recede' hit me when really, what the author meant was 'back a bit earlier in time.'
I am going to hold my head for a bit before I read on. You'll have to wait till this afternoon to hear about amazing archaeology.
At least this vindicates something I taught yesterday. We all have shared vocabulary. We just don't always know what bits of a words meaning someone else shares with us. This poor young academic knows less than most, and ouch, excuse me while I do that holding-head thing.
The problem is that I have just read an academic book review that makes my head whirl. There's nothing wrong with what it's saying, but there's everything wrong with how it's saying it. There are just so many specific words that are used where really the writer wants to say something general. As a result, all the very precise implications of 'recede' hit me when really, what the author meant was 'back a bit earlier in time.'
I am going to hold my head for a bit before I read on. You'll have to wait till this afternoon to hear about amazing archaeology.
At least this vindicates something I taught yesterday. We all have shared vocabulary. We just don't always know what bits of a words meaning someone else shares with us. This poor young academic knows less than most, and ouch, excuse me while I do that holding-head thing.