
Regular as clockwork, one of my regular-as-clockwork issues has come back to plague me. Each time it returns, it does so with new twists. What scholars care about is seldom what the general public either wants to know or needs to learn. The amount of scholarship on a subject can't often be used to set-up a general article or book or chapter on a subject.
In this instance, it's a chapter of a book and the first draft was all my fault. I wrote lovingly about all my favourite types of Medieval literature. This means that I have the signal responsibility of fixing it, for I know the actual relative importance of Medieval literatures and I had done a careful balance between them and the scholarly importance, and I'd completely left out the general public. Since the general public is who the book is for...
Actually, it wasn't all my fault. It's the way we think about the Middle Ages and are taught them. It's the way some of us focus on Arthur, or some on Icelandic sagas or some on hagiography. Even the best overviews are fuelled by the base we learn from.
I can't ever eliminate my own specialisations. All I can do is balance them a bit more and write something that makes sense of Medieval literature so that someone who reads it has a balanced and straightforward entry point. I made a terrible bosh of the first go, and a bad but not quite as bad bosh of the second. And I've had critical assistance along the way. I don't normally need so many drafts! The problem is that I know the subject too closely and from too particular an angle.
It's very good for me to write for those who don't know my subject at all: it's a salutary lesson. Maybe all specialists should write one book (or one chapter, anyhow) for those who know their subject not at all, and get that sense of "Oh, I didn't know I was carrying this bias," and "My goodness, do I really love this bit so much that I completely exclude all those others?" and "This isn't an overview, it's my first doctorate in miniature." In fact, that first doctorate is part of it. These advanced degrees engrave patterns into our brains, and they're not always the patterns we either need or think we have. It does me a great deal of good to question mine.